Exotic pets usually have a low supply in the game which has driven up their value. Exotic pets were either hard to get when they were in game or were ignored for some reason. Many of them were also in game for a short period of time. Lots of players seek out these pets since they are usually harder to get.

	African Wild Dog	Ultra-Rare	UGC Rewards Update July 2023
	Alpaca	Ultra-Rare	Farm Theme 2023
	Bald Eagle	Ultra-Rare	Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux)
	Balloon Unicorn	Legendary	Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux)
	Black-Chested Pheasant	Legendary	Golden Wheat
	Blazing Lion	Legendary	Campfire Cookie
	Border Collie	Rare	Spring Fest 2023 (Robux)
	Bush Elephant	Legendary	Sunshine Games 2024 (Robux)
	Caelum Cervi	Legendary	Pride Update 2023 (Robux)
	Caterpillar	Ultra-Rare	Farm Theme 2023 (Robux)
	Diamond Albatross	Legendary	Golden Clam
	Diamond Amazon	Legendary	Golden Plantain
	Diamond Butterfly	Legendary	Golden Leaf
	Diamond Hummingbird	Legendary	Golden Petunia
	Emperor Gorilla	Legendary	Premium Gorilla Box
	Frost Unicorn	Legendary	Mountain House Update (Robux)
	Giant Anteater	Rare	Jungle Update 2023 (Robux)
	Giant Blue Scarab	Ultra-Rare	Mud Ball
	Giant Gold Scarab	Legendary	Mud Ball
	Glacier Moth	Ultra-Rare	UGC Pet Refresh January 2023
	Goat	Ultra-Rare	Pride Event 2022 (Robux)
	Goose	Rare	Spring Fest 2023 (Robux)
	Groundhog	Ultra-Rare	Groundhog Day 2024
	Happy Clam	Ultra-Rare	Summer Festival 2023
	Honey Badger	Ultra-Rare	UGC Rewards Update September 2024
	Hot Doggo	Legendary	Summer Festival 2023 (Robux)
	Ice Wolf	Ultra-Rare	Winter 2022 (Robux)
	Irish Water Spaniel	Ultra-Rare	UGC Rewards
	Jellyfish	Ultra-Rare	UGC Rewards Update January 2024
	Kookaburra	Ultra-Rare	Aussie Zone Update
	Lion Cub	Ultra-Rare	Safari Update 2023 (Robux)
	Many Mackerel	Ultra-Rare	Summer Festival 2023
	Mechapup	Legendary	Robux
	Mini Pig	Ultra-Rare	Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux)
	Monkey King	Legendary	Monkey Fairground
	Nessie	Legendary	Scottish Pets Update 2023
	Orange Butterfly	Ultra-Rare	Golden Leaf
	Pelican	Ultra-Rare	September 2023 (Robux)
	Peppermint Penguin	Ultra-Rare	Winter 2023 (Robux)
	Pirate Ghost Capuchin Monkey	Legendary	Capuchin Boxes
	Puffin	Ultra-Rare	Christmas 2021
	Purple Butterfly	Ultra-Rare	Leaf
	Ring-tailed Lemur	Rare	Jungle Update 2023 (Robux)
	Royal Mistletroll	Legendary	Golden Mistletoe
	Sheeeeep	Ultra-Rare	Meme Pets Update 2023 (Robux)
	Slime	Ultra-Rare	Halloween 2023
	Sugar Glider	Legendary	Easter 2022 (Robux)
	Tio De Nadal	Legendary	April Fools Day 2023 (Robux)
	Tortuga de la Isla	Ultra-Rare	Summer Festival 2023 (Robux)
	Undead Jousting Horse	Legendary	Halloween 2022 (Robux)
	Winged Tiger	Legendary	Lunar New Year 2023 (Robux)
	Wood Pigeon	Ultra-Rare	Spring Fest 2023